Integration models in the world of composable commerce

Rethinking integration models in composable commerce

Prateek Srivastava
Prateek Srivastava
Principal Engineer Integrations, commercetools
Published 01 March 2024
Estimated reading time minutes

In the ever-evolving landscape of eCommerce, businesses are constantly seeking more efficient ways to integrate their various systems and applications. This integration is crucial for seamless operations, from managing inventory and orders to delivering personalized customer experiences. Common integration models contain the use of a “hub-and-spoke” system where all the validation, transformation, routing and other business rules come into play. 

However, when it comes to composable commerce and best-of-breed components, the integration focus should change to follow composable principles and have leaner integrations instead of smarter pipes. In this blog post, we’ll explore why this shift in perspective is crucial with composable commerce integrations and the role commercetools Connect plays in this context.

Integration models in the world of composable commerce

Understanding composable commerce

Composable commerce is a modern approach to building eCommerce ecosystems that emphasizes flexibility, agility and scalability. It allows businesses to assemble their commerce stack using modular, best-of-breed components rather than relying on monolithic systems. This approach provides the adaptability needed to meet rapidly changing customer demands and market dynamics. One of the most used architecture principles to achieve composable is MACH®, an approach based on API-first and microservices that ensures a modular, adaptable and scalable foundation for building digital ecosystems. 

The hub-and-spoke integration model: “Smart pipes”

The hub-and-spoke integration model, also known as the centralized or Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) model, has been a staple in integration architecture for years. In this model, a central hub (aka, the ESB) acts as an intermediary between various applications and systems (the spokes). These systems rely mostly on their pipes while interconnected with other systems using an API or other interoperability techniques. While this model has been working well, it added a lot of notable limitations when applied to composable commerce, such as: 

1. Complexity in the pipes: Traditional ESBs often have lots of business logic in the “pipes,” creating a monolithic hub in a hub-and-spoke system. This approach results in fragility and all the other problems inherent with monoliths.

2. Lack of adaptability: Smart “pipes” can be inflexible when it comes to adding or changing integrations. Each new integration requires reworking the central hub, potentially causing delays and bottlenecks.

3. Scalability issues: As composable commerce ecosystems grow, the hub can become a performance bottleneck. Adding more integrations or increasing data volume can strain the central hub’s resources.

The case for lean integrations and smart APIs

In contrast, composable commerce thrives on the principle of rich and mature APIs with lean integrations. Composable products generally have APIs that offer stronger domain models, context awareness, optimized performance and flexibility, which help in any aggregations and filtering accomplishing leaner pipes for integrations.

Understanding Smart APIs

Smart APIs refer to the strategic design of individual components, such as APIs or modular services, with intelligence, capability and specific functionality. Here’s a more detailed explanation:

  • Specialized functionality: Smart APIs are designed to perform specific, well-defined functions or services. Each endpoint in the system has a clear purpose, excelling at executing the tasks it is designed for. This specialization allows for a modular architecture where each component contributes a unique value to the overall system.

  • Autonomy and independence: Smart APIs operate autonomously, not heavily reliant on a central orchestrator or hub to function. This autonomy contributes to the flexibility and independence of each component. Changes or updates to one endpoint do not necessarily impact the entire system, fostering a more agile and adaptable architecture.

  • Business logic at the edge: Unlike the traditional approach of having business logic embedded in the central hub or middleware (smart pipes), the “smart APIs” philosophy advocates for pushing business logic to the edges of the system. This means that the intelligence needed to execute specific business processes or functionalities resides within the individual components. This approach reduces the complexity of the central hub, making the system easier to understand, maintain and scale.

  • Scalability and responsiveness: Smart APIs contribute to the scalability of the system by distributing the processing load. As the system grows, additional endpoints can be added, each handling a specific aspect of the overall workload. This decentralized approach allows for more efficient resource utilization and ensures that scaling the system is a modular and straightforward process.

  • Adaptability to change: The “smart APIs” philosophy embraces adaptability. If there is a need to introduce new features, modify existing functionalities or replace a specific component, it can be done without disrupting the entire system. This adaptability is crucial in the rapidly changing landscape of eCommerce, where businesses need to respond swiftly to market trends and customer demands.

Using the Smart APIs with lean integration brings about numerous advantages for businesses aiming to thrive in the ever-evolving eCommerce ecosystem in the following ways: 

  1. Modularity: As composable commerce encourages having intelligent endpoints, where each API is highly capable and specialized, integrations are mostly data mappers with no business logic in the middle. This modularity allows for a fine-grained architecture, where each component serves a specific purpose without unnecessary complexity. With specialized endpoints, businesses can easily adapt and evolve individual components, fostering a flexible and future-proof architecture. This approach aligns perfectly with the ethos of MACH, an architecture that combines microservices, API-first, cloud-native and headless technologies, enabling businesses to swap out or upgrade individual components without disrupting the entire ecosystem. 

  2. Flexibility at its core: With this integration, each application or component connects directly to its counterpart, operating independently of a central hub. This means that businesses can seamlessly add, modify or upgrade integrations without the fear of disrupting the entire system. The result is a nimble and responsive eCommerce ecosystem capable of swiftly adapting to changing market conditions and customer expectations.

  3. Scalability through decentralization: Using a decentralized approach inherently contributes to natural scalability. As composable commerce ecosystems expand, businesses can effortlessly integrate new components without encountering centralized bottlenecks. This decentralized scalability ensures that growth is organic and the system can accommodate increased data volumes as well as additional integrations without compromising performance.

  4. Resilience and fault isolation: By pushing intelligence to the endpoints, this philosophy enhances system resilience. In the event of a failure or issue in one endpoint, the impact is localized and the overall system remains operational. This fault isolation ensures that disruptions are contained, making troubleshooting and maintenance more straightforward. The absence of a central hub simplifies the architecture, reducing the risk of system-wide failures and enhancing the overall reliability of the eCommerce ecosystem.

In the era of composable commerce, where adaptability and agility are paramount, the focus should be on having “lean pipes and smart APIs”. This shift in perspective empowers businesses to build agile and responsive eCommerce ecosystems, ultimately leading to enhanced customer experiences and competitive advantages in the dynamic world of online shopping.

By embracing this “lean pipes and smart APIs” philosophy in commercetools Connect, we are helping organizations break free from the constraints of traditional integration models, fostering innovation and creating future-proof eCommerce solutions.

commercetools Connect: Unleashing integrations potential

commercetools Connect serves as a pivotal component in the world of composable commerce by offering a robust framework for hosting integrations. This powerful solution enables businesses to connect their eCommerce ecosystem with various third-party systems, tools and services. Whether it’s integrating with a CRM, ERP or marketing automation platform, commercetools Connect empowers businesses to create a cohesive and interconnected digital infrastructure.

Here are four top advantages of commercetools Connect:

  1. Flexibility and customization: commercetools Connect recognizes that each business’ needs are unique. The platform allows to customize and launch of tailor-made integrations that perfectly align with a company’s existing systems and workflows. This flexibility ensures that businesses can adapt and grow without the limitations of a one-size-fits-all solution.

  2. Seamless composable commerce: commercetools Connect seamlessly aligns with the philosophy of composable commerce. Instead of forcing businesses into rigid integrations, it enables them to select and integrate components that suit their requirements. This results in an agile and scalable commerce ecosystem that can be modified as business needs change.

  3. Accelerated time-to-market: Connect provides an expanding array of pre-built connectors available through a dynamic marketplace, a collection that continues to grow in tandem with the increasing enthusiasm from our partner networks. By utilizing commercetools Connect’s pre-built connectors and integration templates, businesses can significantly reduce the time it takes to deploy new integrations. This accelerated time-to-market is crucial in today’s fast-paced digital landscape.

  4. Future-Proof SLAs: Connect also takes a proactive approach to ensure the stability and security of hosted integrations. Each integration undergoes a rigorous vetting process, guaranteeing that they meet stringent security standards. These integrations are not only certified and validated for stability and execution but also come with future-proof Service Level Agreements (SLAs). With commercetools Connect, you not only streamline your operations effortlessly but also gain the confidence that your integrations are certified, secure and built to withstand future challenges. 

If you’re interested in learning more about commercetools Connect, contact us today.

Prateek Srivastava
Prateek Srivastava
Principal Engineer Integrations, commercetools

Prateek is a Principal Engineer for integrations at commercetools. With over a decade of experience across eCommerce implementations and operations, he is an expert in seamlessly connecting digital platforms for optimal online performance and scalability.

Related Blog Posts